In the grip of low market confidence, Hong Kong auction houses went ahead with their autumn sales as planned

The Hong Kong autumn auctions 2019 is under way in the middle of recent uncertainties surrounding its art market, which includes factors such as the Sino-US trade war and ongoing political tensions in the Special Administrative Region. However, even with a seemingly precarious economic outlook, Hong Kong auction houses went ahead with their busy autumn seasons as planned.


800px-Hong_Kong_anti-extradition_bill_protest_(48108527758).jpg

▲Ongoing political tensions in Hong Kong


Most notably, the impact of the Hong Kong protests on the art market is that the number of buyers attending auctions in Hong Kong has decreased significantly. The total sales value of the Hong Kong autumn auction 2019 at the Sotheby’s, Poly and Guardian Hong Kong bases generated a total of HK$4,712 million (US$600 million), which reflects a 9 percent decrease from last year.


More specifically, Sotheby’s autumn 2019 Hong Kong sales generated HK$3340 million (US$425.8 million), a decrease of 8.24% compared to the figure from autumn 2018. The total sales value of autumn 2019 at Guardian Hong Kong dropped 9.93% to HK$617 million (US$79 million). Poly Auction Hong Kong earned HK$745 million (US$95 million) in its 2019 autumn series, which saw a 12.87% decline compared to autumn 2018.


Although the total sales value of the Hong Kong autumn auctions declined slightly in 2019, it turns out that there was other head-turning market activity which was taking place under the shadow of these uncertain times in Hong Kong. We have witnessed market stability in the ultra-high-end market - 5 lots were sold for over HK$100 million (US$12.75 million); 10 were sold for over HK$50 million (US$6.375 million); and 38 lots over HK$20 million (US$3.188 million). A few artists such as Sanyu and Yoshitomo Nara smashed their previous auction records this season.


Here is a more detailed view of the sales performance of the Hong Kong autumn auctions 2019.



1. A market slowdown in the modern and contemporary art sector
The auction sales value of modern and contemporary art at Sotheby’s, Poly and Guardian was HK$1,960 million (US$249.9 million) at the Hong Kong autumn auctions 2019, which represented a decrease of 4.8% compared to the figure from autumn 2018. However, plenty of art works still managed to produce satisfactory sales results. 18 works by Yoshitomo Nara sold for HK$360 million (US$45.89 million), while 7 works by Liu Ye sold for HK$110 million (US$14.02 million), which means that pop art continues to rise and fuel an increase in total sales of modern and contemporary art.


According to Sotheby’s Hong Kong, its modern and contemporary art sales raised HK$1,611 million (US$205.3 million), a decrease of 14.17%, and it became the only auction house which saw a decline in its market for modern and contemporary art. This is partly due to the number of modern and contemporary artworks sold by Sotheby’s Hong Kong having decreased to just 30 lots of this season, and partly due to the quantity of lots within the price bracket of “HK$50 million (US$6.375 million) - HK$100 million (US$12.75 million)” seeing a sharp decline compared to that of autumn 2018.


sothebys-com.brightspotcdn.jpg

▲Autumn 2019 Opening Reception at Sotheby’s Hong Kong


Top-Lot-Auction-Scene-Nara.jpg

▲Sotheby’s Hong Kong Modern Art Evening Sale


However, artists including Sanyu, Yoshitomo Nara and Liu Ye, all set new personal records at the Sotheby's 2019 autumn sales. For instance, Chinese-French painter, Sanyu’s latest nude painting – one which represents the zenith of the artist’s creation – was sold at Sotheby’s modern art evening sale for HK$198 million (US$25.24 million). At the same time, Japanese artist Yoshitomo Nara’s monumental painting which was the largest work by this artist ever to be sold at auction, Knife Behind Back, fetched HK$196 million (US$25 million) at Sotheby’s contemporary evening sale in Hong Kong, which smashed the artist’s previous auction record. The results demonstrate that in these times of uncertainty in Hong Kong, the ultra-high-end market remains almost completely stable.


HK0886-1029_web.jpg

▲Sanyu, Nu. Courtesy of Sotheby’s Hong Kong.


HK0885-1142_web.jpg

▲Yoshitomo Nara, Knife Behind Back. Courtesy of Sotheby’s Hong Kong. 


The Guardian Hong Kong modern and contemporary art sales totaled HK$617 million (US$78.65 million), and included 14 lots which sold for over HK$10,0000. Yoshitomo Nara once again led the high-end market for modern and contemporary art. His work, Midnight Vampire, sold for HK$37.15 million (US$4.74 million).


1570674171725.jpg

▲Asian 20th Century and Contemporary Art at the Guardian Hong Kong


Poly Auction Hong Kong garnered HK$745 million (US$94.97 million) from its modern and contemporary art sales. 19 lots sold for over HK$10,0000. Works by artists such as Yoshitomo Nara and Sanyu still managed to fetch high prices at the auction.


8ba13bbded734d0fb2eab2bc146c9a87.jpg

▲Modern and Contemporary Art at Poly Auction Hong Kong


In addition, this season’s sales at Sotheby’s Hong Kong saw a strong performance of Western artists, such as KAWS, whose Untitled (KIMPSONS #1), sold for HK$57.88 million (US$7.378 million), achieving the accolade of fourth-highest seller in the top 10 modern and contemporary artworks which sold in the Hong Kong autumn auction 2019. Furthermore, the number of Western artworks in this season’s auction surpassed the previous amounts at Sotheby’s contemporary evening sale.



2. A remarkable recovery in the market for Antiques
On the contrary, we witnessed a decent seasonal performance in the market for antiques, which generated HK$1,077 million (US$137.3 million) at the three auction houses, and halted the overall downward trend of the previous five seasons. Of significant note, a highly important Qianlong period enamelled glass, offered for sale by one of the world’s leading collectors of Chinese art and antiquities, Robert Tsao, sold for HK$207 million (US$26.39 million) at Sotheby’s autumn 2019 Hong Kong sales, which made it the best seller of this season in Hong Kong. In conclusion, the trend could be an indication of a strong collector base for Chinese artworks.


EG0Y608UUAEEsrc.jpg

▲An Extraordinary Qing Dynasty Enamelled Glass Vase. Courtesy of Sotheby’s Hong Kong.



3. A sharp decline in the market for Chinese painting and calligraphy
Chinese painting and calligraphy auction sales have taken a sharp downward dip, dropping 26.27% to HK$696 million (US$88.71 million) compared to the figure from autumn 2018, which indicates that the market for Chinese painting and calligraphy in Hong Kong is unlikely to eclipse that of mainland China.


However, in coincidence with the 120th anniversary of his birth, the White Cloud Studio by Zhang Daqian, one of the most prestigious Chinese artists of the twentieth century, sold for HK$37.15 million (US$4.74 million) at the Guardian Hong Kong, and led the high-end market for Chinese painting and calligraphy.


IMG_3941.JPG

▲Zhang Daqian, White Cloud Studio. Courtesy of the Guardian Hong Kong.


In general, the uncertainty within Hong Kong art market is heightened by the continuing protests and global market trends. The direction in which the Hong Kong auction market is heading remains unknown.